Authors: Marcin Wodzinski, Connie Webber (Editor), Sarah Cozens
ISBN-13: 9781904113089, ISBN-10: 1904113087
Format: Hardcover
Publisher: Littman Library of Jewish Civilization
Date Published: August 2005
Edition: REV
Wodzinski (Jewish Studies, U. of Wroclaw) re-reads the 200-year history of passionate conflict between those who followed the Jewish Enlightenment, or Haskalah, and those who sided with Hasidism in Poland, and finds previous treatments to contain stereotypes and misinterpretations of contexts sufficient to warrant a new interpretation. He describes the differences between the two schools of thought and the variants that developed around them, anti-Hasidic criticism in the last years of the Polish-Lithuanian Commonwealth, and the growth of influence of the maskilim, or modernizers. He also describes how these debates fit in the context of the conflicts over identity, assimilation, and solidarity amongst Jewish and non- Jewish Poles in a time when Poland was conquered and carved up in the greater European power struggle of the time. He includes a well- chosen collection of primary documents. Distributed in the US by ISBS. Annotation ©2005 Book News, Inc., Portland, OR
1 | The beginnings : anti-Hasidic criticism in the last years of the Polish-Lithuanian commonwealth | 9 |
2 | Characteristics of the Haskalah in the Kingdom of Poland, 1815-1860 | 34 |
3 | The development of anti-Hasidic criticism among the Maskilim of the Congress Kingdom, 1815-1830 | 72 |
4 | Growing interest, growing conflict, 1831-1860 | 116 |
5 | The twilight of the Haskalah and the dawning of integration | 154 |
6 | Hatred or solidarity? : Jewish and Polish-Jewish fraternity in the 1860s | 180 |
7 | Waning enthusiasm : Izraelita and the moderate integration movement | 200 |
8 | The death of an idea : political, historical, and poetic visions of Hasidism | 228 |
Conclusion : between marginalization, demonization, and nostalgia | 249 | |
App. 1 | Calmanson on Hasidism (1797) | 259 |
App. 2 | Stern's report (1818) | 260 |
App. 3 | Radominski on Hasidism (1820) | 264 |
App. 4 | The Lask Kahal's complaint about a Hasidic Shtibl (1820) | 265 |
App. 5 | Schonfeld's report on a Shtibl in Lask (1820) | 266 |
App. 6 | Schonfeld's report on the baths in Czestochowa (1820) | 269 |
App. 7 | Advisory chamber of the Jewish committee on the Hasidic Rabbi in Plock (1829) | 273 |
App. 8 | The hasidim in Pilica (1830) | 274 |
App. 9 | The Maskilic prayer hall in Suwalki (1833) | 276 |
App. 10 | Tugendhold's report on smoking tobacco in the Beit Midrash (1840) | 276 |
App. 11 | Moszkowski's memorandum (1845) | 279 |
App. 12 | Rosen's opinion on Moszkowski's memorandum (1845) | 280 |
App. 13 | Protocol of the inquiry into Hasidic persecutions in Lodz (1848) | 282 |
App. 14 | Report on Tsadik Abraham Twersky of Turisk (1857) | 285 |
App. 15 | Tugendhold on Abraham Twersky of Turisk (1857) | 287 |
App. 16 | Aeolus and Phoebus (a fable) (1863) | 288 |
App. 17 | Tsadik Brukman and the doctors in Piotrkow (1870) | 289 |
App. 18 | Segel on Hasidism (1897) | 295 |
App. 19 | Sokolow on Hasidism (1898) | 297 |