The World of Prometheus: The Politics of Punishing in Democratic Athens » (REPRINT)

"Danielle Allen's book is a strikingly original contribution to classical Greek social and intellectual history and to the study of Greek legal practices. It also has crucial relevance for important debates within contemporary political and legal theory, including the practical implications of communitarianism and jury nullification."--Josiah Ober, Princeton University

"This is an original and refreshing study. . . . It allows us to reconsider contemporary issues, such as jury nullification and communitarianism, from a new perspective. Its range and depth of argument will make it a useful resource."--Craige Champion, Allegheny College

James Davidson - London Review of Books

A very impressive debut, rich enough in arguments, approaches, theories, and facts that one can disagree with a lot of it and still find much which is useful and convincing.

PREFACE xi INTRODUCTION 3
PART ONE: THE PRELIMINARIES 13
CHAPTER ONE What Is Punishment? 15
Introduction 15
"Revenge" versus "Punishment": Rereading the Oresteia 18
Studying Punishment as Authority: Reading the Prometheus Bound 25
Precis 35
CHAPTER TWO Institutional Context 39
Introduction 39
Penal Institutions and Democratic Power 40
The Lay Prosecutor and the Parameters of Judgment 45
CHAPTER THREE Cultural Context 50
Anger/Orge 50
ThE Agon and Honor 59
Reciprocity 62
Social Memory, Social Knowledge 65
Language 68
Conclusion 72
CHAPTER FOUR Punishment and Its Tragic Problems 73
The Mythic Imaginary 73
Method 75
Disease and Remedy 77
Power Tyranny, and Law 86
Conclusion 94
PART TWO: THE PROCESS OF PUNISHING 97
CHAPTER FIVE Initiation, Part One 99
Knowledge, Power, Action 99
Investigation 102
Initiation: Metics, Proxenoi, and Xenoi 107
Initiation: Slaves 109
Initiation: Women 111
CHAPTER SIX Initiation, Part Two 122
The Male Citizen Prosecutor 122
Back to the Bees and Wasps Again 128
The Household: Women and Men Together 134
City as Collective 141
CHAPTER SEVEN The Negotiation of Desert, Part One 147
The Magic of Speech 147
Pity and Anger 148
The First Norm of Public Agency: Deserving to Punish and Dispelling Charges of Sycophancy 151
CHAPTER EIGHT The Negotiation of Desert, Part Two 168
Introduction 168
The Second Norm of Public Agency: Using Social Memory and Law 168
The Rule of Judgment versus the Rule of Law 179
The Rule of Law in Plato and Aristotle 183
The Third Norm of Public Agency: Shaping the Democratic Community 190
CHAPTER NINE Execution 197
War Peace, and the Formalism of Punishment 197
The Details: Punishments and Their Executors 200
Tvo Forms of Memory: Remembering and Forgetting 202
The Symbolism of Remembering and Forgetting 205
War and Peace, the Body and Silence 213
Punishments of Reintegration 224
Punishments that Redefine the "Whole" Community 232
The Amnesty 237
PART THREE: INTERVENTIONS IN THE CONVERSATION 243
CHAPTER TEN Plato's Paradigm Shifts 245
The Symbol of Leontios 245
Reform over Reciprocity 247
The Erasure of Orge 251
Undoing the Athenian "Principle of the Public": The Republic 257
The Just City and the Power of the Symbol 263
The Incurables and the Necessity for Anger/Orge in the Just City of the Laws 277
CHAPTER ELEVEN Aristotle's Compromises 282
On Justice and Desert 282
EPILOGUE: The Reform of Prometheus and Promethean Rebellion 293
APPENDIXES A. The Number of Magistrates in Athens 305
B. The Nature and Scope of Arbitration in Athens 317
C. The Relative Frequency of Penal Words within Each Orator 323
D. Further Argument about the Decree of Cannonus 324
E. Catalog of Cases of Punishing (or Attempts at Punishing) in Tragedy 326
ENDNOTES 333
BIBLIOGRAPHY 405
INDEX 431