Authors: Jeremy D. Safran
ISBN-13: 9780861713424, ISBN-10: 0861713427
Format: Paperback
Publisher: Wisdom Publications MA
Date Published: June 2003
Edition: (Non-applicable)
Psychoanalysis and Buddhism pairs Buddhist psychotherapists together with leading figures in psychoanalysis who have a general interest in the role of spirituality in psychology. The resulting essays present an illuminating discourse on these two disciplines and how they intersect. This landmark book challenges traditional thoughts on psychoanalysis and Buddhism and propels them to a higher level of understanding.
What a joy to witness the realization in this book of a first class discussion of the relations between psychoanalysis and Buddhism! Jeremy Safran, after an excellent historical and
conceptual exposition of the two healing disciplines, assembles an extraordinary array of contributors. Some are psychoanalysts who have been steeped in Buddhist practice over
many years. Others are leading figures in comtemporary psychoanalysis, who have an interest in exploring the areas of overlap, as well as the dissimilarities between the two worlds. The dialogue format of the book dramatically enlivens the text for the reader who is thereby afforded the opportunity to hear some of his or her most pressing questions asked and commented on by a discussant and then responded to by the first author. The contributors cover a wide territory
in the examination of Buddhism from a psychoanalytic point of view-including the concept that is so difficult for the Western mind, the question of no-self. Jack Engler, in an exceptionally lucid and engaging chapter, "Being somebody and being nobody: A re-examination of the understanding of self in psychoanalysis and Buddhism," and in his response to Stephen
Mitchell's probing musings, provides for us a quite wonderful avenue of access to this vexing conception-No, not conception, experience. Safran has provided us with a book that will be
deeply rewarding to both psychoanalysts and Buddhists; it will extend the horizons of both
Acknowledgments | xiii | |
Preface | xv | |
Introduction: Psychoanalysis and Buddhism As Cultural Institutions | 1 | |
Chapter 1. | Being Somebody and Being Nobody: A Reexamination of the Understanding of Self in Psychoanalysis and Buddhism | 35 |
Commentary: Somebodies and Nobodies | 80 | |
Reply: Can We Say What the Self "Really" Is? | 86 | |
Chapter 2. | Tibetan Buddhism and a Mystical Psychoanalysis | 101 |
Commentary: Psychoanalysis as a Spiritual Quest | 115 | |
Reply: The Persistence of Spiritual Shyness in Psychoanalysis | 122 | |
Chapter 3. | The Dissolving of Dissolving Itself | 131 |
Commentary: Imagining Langan: A Transcendence of Self | 146 | |
Reply: A Saturated Solution | 158 | |
Chapter 4. | An Analyst's Surrender | 169 |
Commentary: A Contemplative Response | 189 | |
Reply: Swimming Lessons | 191 | |
Chapter 5. | Moments of Truth--Truths of Moment | 199 |
Commentary: "East Is East and West Is West and Ne'er the Twain Shall Meet" (Or Shall They?) | 221 | |
Reply: East and West Are Already Meeting--What's Shaking Out? | 230 | |
Chapter 6. | Your Ordinary Mind | 251 |
Commentary: Psychoanalysis and Buddhism: Two Extraordinary Paths to an Ordinary Mind | 286 | |
Reply: The Path Is Ordinary Too | 293 | |
Chapter 7. | Transference and Transformation in Buddhism and Psychoanalysis | 301 |
Commentary: Seeking and Subjectivity in Buddhism and Psychoanalysis | 318 | |
Reply: Increasing Our Subjective Freedom | 323 | |
Chapter 8. | The Finger Pointing at the Moon: Zen Practice and the Practice of Lacanian Psychoanalysis | 331 |
Commentary: Where Is the "Spirit" in a Spiritual Conception of Psychoanalysis? | 364 | |
Reply: Psychoanalysis as a Secular and Nontheistic Spirituality | 371 | |
Chapter 9. | A Well-Lived Life: Psychoanalytic and Buddhist Contributions | 387 |
Commentary: Managing Traffic on the Bridge Between Psychoanalysis and Buddhism | 410 | |
Reply: Beyond Eurocentrism and Orientocentrism | 418 | |
List of Contributors | 427 | |
Index | 433 |