Authors: Mark C. Carnes, David Rubel (Editor), Ted Mico (Editor), Ted Mico (Editor), John Miller-Monzon
ISBN-13: 9780805037609, ISBN-10: 0805037608
Format: Paperback
Publisher: Holt, Henry & Company, Inc.
Date Published: November 1996
Edition: Reprint
Mark C. Carnes is the chairman of the department of history at Barnard College, Columbia University, and the executive secretary of the Society of American Historians.
In this widely-acclaimed volume, some of our greatest historians address the facts—and fiction—as seen in Hollywood’s often epic recreations of historical events. Distinghuished historians such as Stephen Ambrose, Antonia Fraser, James McPherson, Gerda Lerner, Dee Brown, Frances FitzGerald, David Levering Lewis, and Simon Schama explore the relationship between film and the historical record. Offering hundreds of movie stills, archival photographs, maps, and other illustrations, along with sidebars on related historical events, Past Imperfect sheds new light on the uses of history in popular culture.
Perhaps this summer's boomlet of historical movies and costume dramas have sparked interest, for this is only one of several recent books by historians examining films set in the past. Editor Carnes (Secret Ritual and Manhood in Victorian America, LJ 8/89) persuaded 60 historical writers, including such popular figures as Gore Vidal, William Manchester, Antonia Frasier, James McPherson, and Frances FitzGerald, to write an original piece on an historical film. The authors gleefully skewer, pick apart, praise, and censure film classics such as Gone with the Wind, Mutiny on the Bounty, A Man for All Seasons, Spartacus, Jurassic Part, Patton, etc. There is, not surprisingly, considerable nitpicking over historical details, but the writers seem to share a common fondness for the movies. Indeed, several confess that their interest in history was first awakened by a film they saw as a child. Film buffs will thoroughly enjoy. Highly recommended for large public libraries and subject collections.-Marianne Cawley, Enoch Pratt Free Lib., Baltimore
Introduction | 9 | |
A Conversation Between Eric Foner and John Sayles | 11 | |
Jurassic Park | 30 | |
The Ten Commandments | 36 | |
Spartacus | 40 | |
Julius Caesar | 44 | |
Henry V: Two Films | 48 | |
Joan of Arc: Three Films | 54 | |
Christopher Columbus: Two Films | 60 | |
Anne of the Thousand Days | 66 | |
A Man for All Seasons | 70 | |
Aguirre, the Wrath of God | 74 | |
Black Robe | 78 | |
The Last of the Mohicans | 82 | |
The Scarlet Empress | 86 | |
1776 | 90 | |
Drums Along the Mohawk | 94 | |
Mutiny on the Bounty | 98 | |
Danton | 104 | |
The Buccaneer: Two Films | 110 | |
The Alamo | 116 | |
The Charge of the Light Brigade | 120 | |
The Young Lincoln: Two Films | 124 | |
Glory | 128 | |
Gone with the Wind | 132 | |
The Birth of a Nation | 136 | |
The Molly Maguires | 142 | |
They Died with Their Boots on | 146 | |
Fort Apache | 150 | |
The Tale of Wyatt Earp: Seven Films | 154 | |
Khartoum | 162 | |
Murder by Decree | 166 | |
Freud | 170 | |
Young Winston | 174 | |
Hester Street | 178 | |
Gallipoli | 182 | |
World War I: Five Films | 186 | |
Reds | 192 | |
Rosa Luxemburg | 196 | |
The Front Page | 200 | |
Matewan | 204 | |
Shanghai Express | 208 | |
Houdini | 212 | |
Sullivan's Travels | 216 | |
Bonnie and Clyde | 220 | |
The Grapes of Wrath | 224 | |
Tora! Tora! Tora! | 228 | |
PT 109 | 232 | |
The Longest Day | 236 | |
Patton | 242 | |
Fat Man and Little Boy | 246 | |
The Human Condition | 250 | |
Gandhi | 254 | |
Tea and Sympathy | 258 | |
The Long Walk Home | 262 | |
Dr. Strangelove | 266 | |
JFK | 270 | |
Mississippi Burning | 274 | |
Malcolm X | 278 | |
Apollo 13 | 284 | |
Apocalypse Now | 288 | |
All the President's Men | 292 | |
Nixon | 296 | |
The Emperor's Last Review | 300 | |
A Conversation Between Mark Carnes and Oliver Stone | 305 | |
The Contributors | 313 | |
Index | 316 |