Authors: Mike Mccarthy, Michael McCarthy
ISBN-13: 9780306463655, ISBN-10: 0306463652
Format: Hardcover
Publisher: Springer-Verlag New York, LLC
Date Published: January 2001
Edition: (Non-applicable)
In the early 1980s the author was asked to investigate the newly discovered wreck of the Xantho, an iron screw steamship active off the Australian coast during the period 1848 to 1872, and to develop a strategy to stop the looting that was occurring at the site. This relatively straightforward assignment turned into a long-term research program for applying maritime archaeology to the conservation of iron-hulled wrecks.
McCarthy, of the Western Australian Maritime Museum in Fremantle, headed a site management project begun in 1983 to protect the wrecked steamship (1848-72). This study represents a landmark in modern maritime archeology by linking underwater archaeologists, biologists, and corrosion specialists for site and lab analyses. The author, who wrote his master's thesis on Captain Broadhurst, provides context for the ship and its captain. Includes photos of ships and shipwrecks, diagrams of their equipment, 19th century charts of Western Australia, information on horsepower, and wages/salaries current in 1870. The extensive bibliography includes archival documents. Annotation c. Book News, Inc., Portland, OR (booknews.com)
Chapter 1 | Introduction | |
1. | Description, Analysis and Explanation at a Steam Ship Wreck | 1 |
1.1 | Description | 1 |
1.2 | Analysis and Explanation | 3 |
Chapter 2 | Xantho and Broadhurst in context | |
2. | The Context of the Find | 7 |
2.1 | Marine Engineering | 8 |
2.1.1 | The iron hull | 8 |
2.1.2 | Marine propulsion | 11 |
2.1.3 | Boilers, condensers, and other machinery | 15 |
2.1.4 | The advent of compounding | 19 |
2.1.5 | The "ideal" 1870s steamer | 24 |
2.2 | The Colonial Setting | 24 |
2.2.1 | Steamers in Western Australia | 25 |
2.3 | The Broadhursts in Context: An Inadequate Record | 29 |
2.3.1 | Victorian squatters | 32 |
2.3.2 | Northwest pastoralists | 32 |
2.3.3 | Pearlers in the northwest | 36 |
2.4 | Broadhurst and Xantho | 40 |
2.4.1 | Xantho: A transport for pearl divers | 42 |
2.4.2 | Xantho the tramp steamer: An indigenous record? | 44 |
2.4.3 | The last voyage | 46 |
Chapter 3 | Xantho-the transformations | |
3. | A Wealth of Information | 48 |
3.1 | The Specifications: Construction as a Paddle Steamer | 48 |
3.2 | The First Transformation | 52 |
3.2.1 | Xantho: A hybrid refugee from the scrap heap | 52 |
3.3 | The Loss of Xantho: The Second Transformation | 54 |
3.3.1 | Abandonment behavior and its effect on the material record | 56 |
3.4 | Breakup and Salvage: The Third Transformation | 57 |
3.5 | Another Contemporary Record of Xantho? | 59 |
3.6 | Xantho: A Navigational Hazard | 61 |
Chapter 4 | The wreck examined | |
4. | Processes in Wreck Site Analysis | 65 |
4.1 | The Discovery and Inspection of the Site | 65 |
4.2 | Early Iron and Steamship Archaeology Examined | 67 |
4.3 | A Predisturbance Study: New Direction in 1983 | 68 |
4.3.1 | Natural transformation forces analyzed | 70 |
4.3.2 | Results of the predisturbance survey | 73 |
4.4 | Anomalous Features Identified | 75 |
4.5 | Site Survey and Test Excavation | 77 |
4.6 | Test Excavation Method | 79 |
4.7 | Results of the Survey and Test Excavation | 81 |
4.8 | The Application of Anodes | 84 |
Chapter 5 | Site formation processes | |
5. | Postdepositional Processes at an Iron Wreck | 88 |
5.1 | The Effect of Corrosion and Concretion | 88 |
5.2 | Muckelroy's Index Applied to Modern Sites | 90 |
5.3 | John Riley's Observations: The Waterline Theory | 95 |
5.4 | Other Commonalities Observed | 97 |
5.5 | The Formation of the Xantho Site | 104 |
Chapter 6 | The investigation continues in the archives | |
6. | The Archival and Material Records at Odds | 108 |
6.1 | The Material Record Incorrectly Read | 110 |
6.2 | Distortions in the Written Record | 112 |
6.3 | The Naval Origins of the Xantho Engine | 113 |
6.4 | Broadhurst Revisited | 118 |
6.4.1 | Pearling at Shark Bay | 120 |
6.4.2 | American influences | 120 |
6.4.3 | Broadhurst: A great success | 121 |
6.4.4 | Broadhurst: The consistent failure | 122 |
6.4.5 | Broadhurst's other enterprises | 122 |
Chapter 7 | Excavations at the site | |
7. | Excavation Processes | 125 |
7.1 | The Research Strategy | 125 |
7.2 | Preliminary Fieldwork | 126 |
7.3 | Further Site Assessments | 127 |
7.4 | The Engine Cut Free | 129 |
7.5 | Budgets and Rewards | 130 |
7.6 | The Iron and Steamship Wreck Seminar | 131 |
7.7 | The Excavation | 132 |
7.8 | The Engine Removed | 134 |
7.9 | The Excavation and Recording of the Stern | 135 |
7.10 | The Stern Cut Free | 139 |
7.11 | Subsequent On-Site Excavations | 141 |
7.12 | An Unsuccessful Attempt to Examine Nineteenth-Century Shipbuilding Method | 143 |
7.13 | A Clue to the Rapidity of Concretion Formation | 144 |
7.14 | Results of the 1984-1994 Excavations | 145 |
Chapter 8 | Excavation in the laboratory | |
8. | Deconcretion: Excavation and Experimentation | 147 |
8.1 | The Removal of Chlorides Explained | 149 |
8.2 | Deconcretion of the Outer Surfaces | 149 |
8.3 | Engineering Anomalies Identified | 156 |
8.4 | Further Deconcretion | 158 |
8.5 | Unexpected Conservation Problems | 159 |
8.6 | Further Evidence of Abandonment Behaviour | 159 |
8.7 | The Externals Totally Deconcreted | 160 |
8.8 | The Engine Model | 161 |
8.9 | Engine Markings: Broadhurst Reassessed | 163 |
8.10 | The Disassembly of the Engine | 166 |
8.10.1 | The direct flame method applied to the Xantho | 167 |
8.11 | A Concretion Formation Model Proposed | 167 |
8.12 | Further Experiments in Deconcretion | 168 |
8.13 | Analogy in Engine Excavation | 169 |
8.14 | Dismantling the Machinery | 170 |
8.15 | Entering the Cylinders | 173 |
8.16 | The British Standard Whitworth (BSW) Thread | 174 |
8.17 | Further Evidence of Poor Maintenance | 175 |
8.18 | A Setback in the Final Stages | 177 |
Chapter 9 | Conclusion | |
9. | Iron Wrecks as Archaeological Sites | 180 |
9.1 | Description and Analysis | 181 |
9.2 | Analysis and Explanation | 185 |
9.3 | The Xantho/Broadhurst Exhibition | 194 |
Appendices | ||
10. | Appendix 1: Horsepower | 196 |
10.1 | Nominal Horsepower | 197 |
10.2 | Indicated Horse Power | 198 |
11. | Appendix 2: Wages and Salaries in 1870 | 200 |
Bibliography | 201 |